CATAN Premium Robber & Metal Dice: Tiger's Eye vs Hematite
By FanRoll by Metallic Dice Games | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Tiger's Eye and Hematite CATAN Premium Robber & Metal Dice Sets to find the right upgrade for your game.
Quick answer
Choose the Tiger's Eye set if you want a warm, golden-brown stone robber with a lower price point; pick the Hematite set if you prefer a sleek, dark metallic look and are willing to pay slightly more for the dramatic contrast.
What sets these premium upgrades apart?
Both the Tiger's Eye and Hematite CATAN Premium Robber & Metal Dice Sets include a genuine stone robber and a pair of solid metal dice forged in the official CATAN dice mold. The key differences are the stone type and the price.
The Tiger's Eye robber features a golden-brown stone with a silky, chatoyant sheen, giving your board a warm, earthy accent. The Hematite robber offers a dark, metallic gray-black finish that creates a bold, modern contrast against the colorful CATAN tiles.
Price-wise, the Tiger's Eye set is currently available at a lower cost (USD 19.19) compared to the Hematite set (USD 22.49), making it the more budget-friendly entry point into premium CATAN accessories.
Shared features: metal dice and official mold
Both sets include the same pair of solid metal dice, which are made in the official CATAN dice mold. This means the dice match the standard size and pip layout, so they roll and read exactly like the original plastic dice but with a satisfying heft and durability.
Because the dice are identical in both sets, your choice comes down entirely to the robber stone and the price difference.
Tiger's Eye vs Hematite: trade-offs at a glance
- Stone appearance: Tiger's Eye offers a warm, golden-brown sheen that shifts in the light. Hematite provides a uniform, dark metallic finish that stays consistent.
- Price: Tiger's Eye set costs USD 19.19, while Hematite set costs USD 22.49. The difference is USD 3.30. If budget is your main concern, Tiger's Eye gives you the same metal dice for less.
- Visual contrast on the board: Hematite's dark robber creates a stronger contrast against most CATAN tiles, especially the lighter resource hexes. Tiger's Eye blends more naturally with earth tones.
- Collectibility: Both are part of a four-set collection. Starting with either gives you the option to mix or complete the set later. Consider which stone you'd want to display first, then collect the others over time.
Product facts at a glance
- CATAN® Premium Robber & Metal Dice Set- Tiger's Eye: Tiger's Eye robber is a premium stone piece with a golden-brown, chatoyant finish. The warm tones complement boards with green and blue hexes, adding a natural, organic feel to your game.
CATAN® Premium Robber & Metal Dice Set- Tiger's Eye - CATAN® Premium Robber & Metal Dice Set- Hematite: Hematite robber is a premium stone piece with a dark, metallic gray-black appearance. The high-contrast look stands out on any board, making the robber easy to spot and giving your setup a sleek, modern aesthetic.
CATAN® Premium Robber & Metal Dice Set- Hematite
Which set fits your game?
Best for
- Players who want a warm, natural-looking robber and the lowest price point — choose Tiger's Eye.
- Players who prefer a bold, modern aesthetic and don't mind spending a few extra dollars — choose Hematite.
Not for
- Anyone who expects different dice between the two sets — the metal dice are identical.
- Players who dislike stone texture variations — natural stone may have minor surface differences.
